Skip to content

Football Frankly

Straight football. No spin.

Honest takes.
Real context.
For people who actually watch the games.

College Football

AP Top 25 rattled again; CFP next

OSU falls, Miami escapes; Playoff Dozen Countdown on tap. Reviews, previews, Heisman Watch all here

Graphic from the minds of Hall of Football staff
Graphic from the minds of Hall of Football staff

🏈🏈With contributions from The Sports Xchange staff🏈🏈

Tuesday is Election Day across America, but college football fans will be watching for white smoke rising from the chimney atop ESPN headquarters.

Well, an imaginary chimney. Check our graphic.

College Football Playoff committee members will gather to reveal their first Top 25 rankings Tuesday at 7 p.m. ET on ESPN. Like a papal conclave, the deliberations take place behind closed doors. Unlike the Vatican, the committee can expect millions of people to second-guess its decisions before the smoke clears.

And what a mess the committee inherits.

Halloween weekend delivered another shakeup when USC knocked off No. 2 Ohio State, 30–18, sending the Buckeyes tumbling nine places to No. 11 in Sunday’s Associated Press poll. Top-ranked Miami barely escaped Bill Belichick’s North Carolina team, 38–35, while Georgia climbed to No. 2, unbeaten Utah jumped to No. 3 and undefeated UCLA entered the top five.

For the third consecutive week, the nation’s No. 2 team lost. College football last witnessed that particular demolition sequence in 2007.

Now the committee must sort through unbeaten contenders, injured quarterbacks, head-to-head results and a Southeastern Conference that occupies 10 of the AP’s 25 positions.

Consider Notre Dame and BYU. The Irish rank fourth, three spots ahead of the Cougars, despite losing to BYU earlier this season. Ohio State, meanwhile, must explain two defeats, although injured starting quarterback Julian Sayin missed the latest one.

And Tuesday’s verdict might not survive next Saturday.

No. 1 Miami visits No. 4 Notre Dame, No. 3 Utah hosts No. 7 BYU in the Holy War, and No. 2 Georgia travels to No. 12 Ole Miss. Three games capable of sending the committee back into its chambers with a fresh set of headaches.

Tuesday’s rankings are only the beginning. The actual 12-team playoff field will not be selected until December 6.

By then, the committee might need a bigger chimney.

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Here is the new AP Top 25, followed by the players and performances that turned another Saturday into a rankings demolition derby.

AP Top 25 rattled again; CFP next (2)

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Saturday’s Top Games — Week 9

🏈 USC 30, No. 2 Ohio State 18 🏈

Lincoln Riley may have saved his job Saturday night. USC quarterback Jayden Maiava threw for 222 yards, and freshman receiver Trent Mosley turned the Trojans’ second offensive play into a 69-yard touchdown as USC stunned Ohio State at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum.

Ohio State played without injured starting quarterback Julian Sayin, but backup Luke Fahey threw for 260 yards and running back Bo Jackson gained 121 on the ground. Buckeyes receiver Jeremiah Smith caught 10 passes for 83 yards and a touchdown. Ohio State outgained USC 464–338 and controlled the ball for nearly 40 minutes, yet settled for three first-half field goals and did not score a touchdown until the fourth quarter.

USC’s defense and big plays made the difference. Freshman tight end Mark Bowman added a 70-yard reception, and the Trojans never trailed.

For the third consecutive week, the nation’s No. 2 team lost.

AP movement: Ohio State fell nine places to No. 11. USC entered the poll at No. 18.

🏈 No. 4 Indiana 23, Minnesota 16 (OT) 🏈

My dear wife Susie gave up on Indiana with 19 seconds remaining. Minnesota kicker Luke Drzewiecki just drilled a 60-yard field goal to put the Gophers ahead, 16–13, and my wife figured the Hoosiers were finished.

“Game’s over,” she said.

“Haven’t you been watching football lately?” I asked. “There are 19 seconds left.”

Bang! Indiana backup quarterback Grant Wilson connected with Charlie Becker for 33 yards. After an incompletion, Paddy McAteer trotted out to attempt a 60-yard field goal with two seconds remaining.

Good! Overtime!

Indiana’s kicking game already produced a blocked attempt, a miss and a botched snap-and-hold sequence, but McAteer delivered when nothing less would do. It was the longest field goal in Indiana history and, according to the school’s postgame notes, the first FBS game in which both teams kicked field goals of at least 60 yards.

Becker was not finished. On the first play of overtime, Wilson found him for a 25-yard touchdown. Indiana’s defense stopped Minnesota on its possession, completing another narrow escape for coach Curt Cignetti.

Becker finished with eight catches for 149 yards and the winning score. Indiana needed overtime for the second consecutive week.

AP movement: Indiana slipped from No. 4 to No. 6. Minnesota remained unranked.

🏈 No. 20 Boise State 46, Texas State 45 🏈

Boise State led 28–3 at halftime and appeared headed for a comfortable seventh consecutive victory.

Then Texas State scored 36 unanswered points.

Bobcats quarterback Brad Jackson threw for 327 yards and four touchdowns while Texas State transformed a 25-point deficit into a 39–28 fourth-quarter lead. Boise State’s starting quarterback Maddux Madsen departed with a knee injury, leaving backup Max Cutforth to rescue the Broncos.

Cutforth threw three touchdown passes in the final seven minutes, including an 18-yarder to Akeem Wright with 2:40 remaining that put Boise State ahead for good.

Three lead changes occurred in the final five minutes. Texas State nearly completed one of the season’s most remarkable comebacks, only to watch Cutforth engineer another.

Somewhere along the way, the newly expanded Pac-12 discovered its own version of football after dark.

AP movement: Boise State remained No. 20.

🏈 Iowa State 51, No. 24 Oklahoma State 49 🏈

One hundred points. More than 1,100 combined yards. And a penalty that helped decide a game already overflowing with offensive fireworks.

Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker threw for 323 yards and five touchdowns, but the Cowboys needed another fourth-quarter rally after trailing Iowa State by 10 points in the second half.

Wyatt Young scored with 53 seconds remaining to put Oklahoma State ahead 49–48. His unsportsmanlike-conduct penalty after the touchdown pushed the ensuing kickoff back 15 yards.

Iowa State quarterback Jaylen Raynor immediately connected with Jamal Polite for 33 yards, moving the Cyclones into field-goal position. After three rushing plays, Kyle Konrardy kicked the winning 34-yard field goal as time expired.

Iowa State finished with 581 yards. The teams combined for six offensive touchdowns covering at least 40 yards.

AP movement: Oklahoma State dropped out of the Top 25. Iowa State remained unranked.

🏈 No. 1 Miami 38, North Carolina 35 🏈

Bill Belichick nearly collected the signature victory of his young college coaching career, but Miami quarterback Darian Mensah and the Hurricanes escaped Chapel Hill with their unbeaten season intact.

North Carolina quarterback Billy Edwards Jr. completed 28 of 34 passes for 341 yards and four touchdowns. The Tar Heels led 28–24 in the fourth quarter before Miami answered with two touchdowns.

Mensah completed 22 of 29 passes for 274 yards and three scores. His nine-yard touchdown pass to receiver Malachi Toney gave Miami a 38–28 advantage with 2:33 remaining.

North Carolina responded with a touchdown at 1:38, then recovered two consecutive onside kicks. Both recoveries were nullified by penalties—offside on the first attempt and an illegal block on the second.

Miami recovered the third attempt and ran out the clock.

For a team ranked No. 1, the Hurricanes certainly provided more suspense than comfort. Next comes No. 4 Notre Dame in South Bend.

AP movement: Miami remained No. 1.

🏈 No. 8 BYU 27, Arizona State 20 🏈

BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier threw for 236 yards, and running back Sione Moa scored twice as the Cougars survived Arizona State. The Sun Devils erased a 14-point deficit to tie the game at 17 before BYU regained control.

But the game’s most memorable touchdown was one that should not have counted.

On BYU’s opening possession, Bachmeier fumbled during a goal-line sneak, and Moa recovered the ball near the 2-yard line before carrying it into the end zone. Replay officials awarded the touchdown after an extended review.

The Big 12 later acknowledged the error. Moa could recover the ball but could not advance it under the applicable replay rule. BYU should have faced third-and-goal from the 2.

Moa scored another touchdown with 2:09 remaining to secure the victory.

BYU’s third consecutive game involving officiating controversy gives the Cougars another conversation starter ahead of Saturday’s Holy War against Utah.

AP movement: BYU climbed from No. 8 to No. 7.

🏈South Carolina 42, Oklahoma 25 🏈

South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers produced one of Saturday’s most impressive individual performances, accounting for five touchdowns in a road victory over Oklahoma.

Sellers threw for 301 yards and three touchdowns and ran for another 96 yards and two scores. He connected with DJ Black for an 84-yard touchdown and Mazeo Bennett Jr. for a 79-yarder as the Gamecocks built a 35–10 advantage.

Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer threw two fourth-quarter touchdown passes to Ivan Carreon, but the Sooners never seriously threatened to complete the comeback.

South Carolina finished with 521 yards, won its third consecutive game and moved back into the national rankings.

AP movement: South Carolina entered the poll at No. 23.

🏈 Syracuse 30, No. 19 SMU 27 🏈

Syracuse quarterback Steve Angeli connected with Noah Meyers for the winning touchdown with 17 seconds remaining as the Orange rallied past SMU in the JMA Wireless Dome.

Angeli completed 21 of 34 passes for 200 yards, while Syracuse’s defense recorded four sacks, recovered two fumbles and limited SMU to 70 rushing yards.

Mustangs quarterback Kevin Jennings threw for 351 yards and two touchdowns, but SMU could not protect its fourth-quarter lead.

Syracuse improved to 4–4, claiming its second consecutive ACC victory after a difficult start to the season.

AP movement: SMU dropped out of the Top 25. Syracuse remained unranked.

🏈 No. 13 Texas Tech 34, No. 22 Arizona 26 🏈

Texas Tech running back J’Koby Williams rushed for 175 yards, including a 64-yard fourth-quarter touchdown, as the Red Raiders overcame a 17–10 halftime deficit against Arizona.

Quarterback Tommy Castellanos threw two touchdown passes and ran for another, but Williams and the ground game ultimately decided the matchup. Texas Tech rushed for 328 yards while limiting Arizona to just 12 net rushing yards.

Wildcats quarterback Noah Fifita threw for 417 yards, including a 94-yard touchdown to Isaiah Mizell. Arizona receiver Mizell finished with 182 yards, but the Wildcats could not overcome Tech’s second-half surge.

AP movement: Texas Tech remained No. 13. Arizona dropped from No. 22 to No. 24.

🏈 No. 3 Georgia 27, No. 17 Florida 8 🏈

Georgia smothered Florida’s running game and controlled the neutral-site rivalry at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta.

The Bulldogs rushed for 217 yards while limiting the Gators to 48. Quarterback Gunner Stockton threw for only 101 yards, but Georgia needed little aerial production after building a 24–0 halftime lead.

Nate Frazier led the Bulldogs with 67 rushing yards. Florida quarterback Tramell Jones Jr. threw for 172 yards, but the Gators could not mount a serious challenge until the fourth quarter.

Georgia improved to 7–1 and earned a move to No. 2 in Sunday’s poll. A much tougher assignment awaits Saturday at Ole Miss.

AP movement: Georgia rose from No. 3 to No. 2. Florida fell from No. 17 to No. 25.

🏈 No. 6 Utah 49, Cincinnati 25 🏈

Utah quarterback Devon Dampier threw three touchdown passes, and the Utes scored twice on defense to overwhelm Cincinnati.

The game effectively ended before halftime, when Utah built a 42–6 lead. Rabbit Evans returned a fumble 51 yards for a touchdown, and Elijah Davis intercepted a pass and returned it 39 yards for another score.

Dampier passed for 260 yards and three touchdowns. Receiver Hunter Andrews gained 112 yards, including a 59-yard scoring reception.

Utah finished with 534 yards of offense, 268 on the ground, and improved to 8–0 heading into a showdown with BYU.

AP movement: Utah climbed from No. 6 to No. 3.

🏈 No. 12 Ole Miss 45, Auburn 15 🏈

Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss passed for 263 yards and two touchdowns and rushed for 65 yards and another score as the Rebels pulled away from Auburn.

Auburn trailed only 17–15 in the third quarter before Chambliss scored on a 26-yard run. He followed with fourth-quarter touchdown passes to Caleb Cunningham and Horatio Fields, while backup quarterback Deuce Knight completed the scoring with a 17-yard run.

The Rebels scored the final 28 points and held Auburn to 63 rushing yards. Sophomore running back Shekai Mills-Knight added 71 yards and a touchdown.

Georgia visits Oxford next Saturday in one of the season’s pivotal SEC matchups.

AP movement: Ole Miss remained No. 12.

🏈 Oregon 34, No. 20 Northwestern 26 🏈

Oregon quarterback Dylan Raiola passed for 336 yards as the Ducks rallied from a 14-point deficit to knock Northwestern out of the rankings.

Receiver Dakorien Moore caught passes for 128 yards, helping Oregon erase a 20–13 halftime deficit. The Ducks outscored Northwestern 21–6 after intermission.

Northwestern quarterback Aidan Chiles produced 281 passing yards and 93 rushing yards, but Oregon’s fourth-quarter surge decided the game.

AP movement: Northwestern dropped out of the Top 25. Oregon received 55 votes but remained unranked.

🏈 Iowa 30, No. 25 Wisconsin 0 🏈

Iowa quarterback Hank Brown threw for 222 yards and two touchdowns as the Hawkeyes dominated Wisconsin at Kinnick Stadium.

Brown connected with DJ Vonnahme and Tony Diaz for scoring passes, while Vonnahme added a rushing touchdown. Kicker Caden Buhr made three field goals, including a 54-yarder.

Wisconsin managed only nine first downs and 52 rushing yards, never threatening to end the shutout.

The victory propelled Iowa into the national rankings as Wisconsin disappeared.

AP movement: Iowa entered the Top 25 at No. 21. Wisconsin dropped out.

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Looking Ahead — Week 10

All games Saturday, Nov. 7, unless otherwise noted. All times Easter

🏈 No. 1 Miami at No. 4 Notre Dame — 7:30 p.m., NBC/Peacock 🏈

Thirty-eight years after the infamous “Catholics vs. Convicts” showdown, Miami and Notre Dame meet again with national championship implications.

Miami quarterback Darian Mensah takes an unbeaten team into South Bend after throwing three touchdown passes in a narrow 38–35 victory over North Carolina. Receiver Malachi Toney, with 73 catches and 13 touchdowns, gives the Hurricanes another potential Heisman contender.

Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr gets his biggest opportunity of the season, particularly after Miami’s secondary allowed North Carolina quarterback Billy Edwards Jr. to throw for 341 yards and four touchdowns.

The Irish rank fourth despite losing to BYU earlier this season. A victory over Miami would make that head-to-head debate considerably less important.

College GameDay will be in South Bend. No surprise there.

🏈 No. 7 BYU at No. 3 Utah — Noon, ABC 🏈

Holy War. Unbeaten Utah. Once-beaten BYU. A Big 12 championship race and national playoff implications.

What else could anybody want?

Utah quarterback Devon Dampier leads an offense that just shredded Cincinnati for 534 yards in a 49–25 victory. The Utes are 8–0, including 5–0 in conference play, and own the inside track to the Big 12 championship game.

BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier and running back Sione Moa helped the Cougars escape Arizona State, 27–20, although another acknowledged Big 12 officiating error overshadowed the result.

BYU won the last three meetings with Utah, including a 24–21 victory last season. This is their first meeting with both teams ranked among the nation’s top 10.

Rivalry games seldom need additional fuel. This one comes with a tanker truck.

🏈 No. 2 Georgia at No. 12 Ole Miss — 7:30 p.m., ABC 🏈

Georgia’s defense dominated Florida, limiting the Gators to 48 rushing yards in a 27–8 victory. Now the Bulldogs must deal with an Ole Miss quarterback who knows how to beat them.

Trinidad Chambliss accounted for five touchdowns without an interception in two meetings with Georgia last season, helping Ole Miss win both encounters, including a College Football Playoff quarterfinal at the Sugar Bowl.

Chambliss threw for 263 yards and accounted for three touchdowns against Auburn on Saturday. He also rushed for 65 yards, giving Georgia another dimension to defend.

Bulldogs quarterback Gunner Stockton will need more production than the 101 passing yards Georgia required against Florida. Ole Miss enters with two losses and little margin for another.

🏈 Oregon at No. 11 Ohio State — 3:30 p.m., CBS 🏈

Ohio State faces an unfamiliar predicament: two losses, a nine-place tumble in the rankings and uncertainty surrounding starting quarterback Julian Sayin, whose injury kept him out of Saturday’s 30–18 loss at USC.

Backup Luke Fahey threw for 260 yards against the Trojans, but the Buckeyes converted too little of their offensive production into points. Receiver Jeremiah Smith caught 10 passes and scored Ohio State’s only touchdown.

Oregon also turned to a new quarterback. Dylan Raiola, who transferred from Nebraska, threw for 336 yards in the Ducks’ comeback victory over Northwestern after Dante Moore was sidelined for the season.

Both teams carry quarterback questions into a matchup that could determine whether either remains a serious playoff contender.

🏈 No. 9 Alabama at No. 15 LSU — 3:30 p.m., ABC 🏈

Alabama quarterback Keelon Russell and LSU quarterback Sam Leavitt lead two explosive offenses into Death Valley, where another chapter of the Crimson Tide–Tigers rivalry promises to reshape the SEC race.

Russell enters with 2,057 passing yards and 15 touchdowns. Leavitt counters with 2,173 yards and 17 scoring passes.

Both teams stand 6–2, and each needs another quality victory to strengthen its playoff résumé. LSU brings an offense averaging more than 40 points per game, while Alabama scores better than 38.

First-year LSU coach Lane Kiffin also gets a chance to confront Alabama, where he once served as offensive coordinator.

Plenty of storylines before anybody bothers to mention the scoreboard.

🏈 No. 8 Kentucky at No. 16 Tennessee — 6:15 p.m., ESPN 🏈

Kentucky occupies unfamiliar territory near the top of the SEC standings at 7–1 overall and 5–1 in conference play. Tennessee, meanwhile, is 6–2 and still trying to overcome two defeats decided by a combined six points.

The Volunteers bring a dangerous running game led by DeSean Bishop, who enters with 957 rushing yards. Receiver Mike Matthews provides another threat, with 528 receiving yards.

Tennessee also carries history on its side, winning the last four meetings, including a 56–34 victory in 2025.

Kentucky needs to prove its place among the SEC leaders is no accident. Tennessee needs to win a big game instead of coming close.

🏈 No. 10 Texas at No. 19 Missouri — Noon, ESPN 🏈

Texas quarterback Arch Manning and Missouri quarterback Austin Simmons meet in Columbia with both teams 6–2 and competing for position in a crowded SEC playoff picture.

Manning’s season remains an uneven mixture of obvious talent and inconsistent offensive production. Running back Raleek Brown gives Texas another way to attack a Missouri defense that generally makes rushing yards difficult.

Missouri counters with running back Jamal Roberts and receivers Cayden Lee and Donovan Olugbode. Texas fields one of the nation’s stronger defenses against both the run and pass, leaving Simmons with a demanding assignment.

One of these teams will emerge with a valuable seventh victory. The other will carry three losses into the final weeks.

🏈 No. 5 UCLA at Minnesota — Noon, FOX 🏈

Minnesota came within 19 seconds of upsetting Indiana. Its reward? Another unbeaten opponent.

UCLA climbed to No. 5 after shutting out Nevada, 27–0, improving to 8–0 behind a defense allowing only 13.4 points per game. The Bruins surrender fewer than 90 rushing yards per contest, presenting another challenge for a Minnesota offense that struggled to run against Indiana.

Quarterback Ty Dieffenbach directs UCLA’s offense following the season-ending injury to Nico Iamaleava. Running back Wayne Knight gives the Bruins a productive ground threat.

Minnesota quarterback Drake Lindsey and running back Darius Taylor will try to do what nearly worked against Indiana: keep the game close and make the unbeaten visitors earn everything.

The Gophers already know how close they can come. Now they need to finish.

🏈 No. 21 Iowa at Northwestern — 7:30 p.m., FOX 🏈

Iowa climbed into the Top 25 after shutting out Wisconsin, 30–0. Northwestern dropped out following a 34–26 loss to Oregon.

Both teams are 6–2, giving this Big Ten matchup more significance than their respective rankings might suggest.

Iowa quarterback Hank Brown threw two touchdown passes against Wisconsin, while tight end DJ Vonnahme continues to emerge as a useful offensive weapon.

Northwestern quarterback Aidan Chiles accounted for 374 combined passing and rushing yards against Oregon. Receiver Griffin Wilde gives him a productive downfield target.

Iowa enters with one of the nation’s stingiest defenses, allowing only 12.5 points per game. Northwestern averages more than 33.

Something will give in Evanston.

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Heisman Watch: Mensah Gains, Smith Loses Ground

Miami quarterback Darian Mensah emerged from Halloween weekend as the leading contender for the Heisman Trophy, although he might eventually need to overcome somebody standing in his own huddle.

Hurricanes receiver Malachi Toney is making a compelling argument of his own.

Meanwhile, Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith continues rewriting school and conference records, but another Buckeyes defeat threatens to undermine his candidacy.

Saturday illustrated how quickly the Heisman race can change. Mensah completed 22 of 29 passes for 274 yards and three touchdowns as No. 1 Miami escaped North Carolina, 38–35. Toney caught seven passes for 75 yards and two touchdowns, including a nine-yard scoring reception that helped preserve Miami’s unbeaten record.

At USC, Smith caught 10 passes for 83 yards and a touchdown, breaking the Big Ten career record with his 40th touchdown reception. Unfortunately, Ohio State lost 30–18, dropping to 6–2.

Smith did his job. The Buckeyes did not do theirs.

That distinction should matter when voters evaluate an award recognizing the nation’s most outstanding player. But team victories, championship prospects and the ability to deliver memorable moments in November inevitably influence the outcome.

Mensah enters the final month of the regular season with 2,425 passing yards, 25 touchdowns and just one interception. His 80.7 percent completion rate is remarkable.

Toney already owns 73 receptions for 1,027 yards and 13 touchdowns. Ohio State’s Smith counters with 62 catches, 1,067 yards and 13 touchdowns.

Two receivers. Thirteen touchdowns apiece. Just 40 receiving yards separate them.

Their quarterbacks and team records could ultimately provide the difference.

And Miami faces an intriguing historical possibility. Only once in Heisman history did teammates finish first and second in the voting: Army’s Doc Blanchard and Glenn Davis in 1945.

Eighty-one years later, Mensah and Toney could challenge that distinction.

First, however, Miami must visit Notre Dame on Saturday.

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Heisman — Top Five

Our editorial assessment entering November 7, not an official ballot.

AP Top 25 rattled again; CFP next (3)

Who Helped Themselves

Darian Mensah, QB, Miami: Three touchdown passes without an interception helped Miami survive North Carolina and protected his position atop the race. His next opponent, Notre Dame, offers the kind of national stage that can turn a statistical favorite into the voters’ clear choice.

Malachi Toney, WR, Miami: His two touchdowns against North Carolina tied Leonard Hankerson’s Miami single-season record of 13 scoring receptions, established in 2010. Toney reached that figure in only eight games. His production also creates an unusual complication for Mensah: two outstanding players from the same offense competing for votes.

CJ Carr, QB, Notre Dame: Completed 19 of 29 passes for 210 yards and two touchdowns in a 35–13 victory over Navy. Carr’s season ratio stands at 18 touchdown passes against one interception. A victory over top-ranked Miami could change his position in the Heisman race overnight, particularly if he outplays Mensah.

Trinidad Chambliss, QB, Ole Miss: Rebounded from a three-interception performance against Texas by throwing for 263 yards and two touchdowns and rushing for 65 yards and another score against Auburn. Georgia visits Oxford on Saturday. Chambliss needs a signature performance against a highly ranked opponent to elevate his candidacy.

Drew Mestemaker, QB, Oklahoma State: Five touchdown passes and 323 yards against Iowa State gave Mestemaker 25 touchdown passes and 2,649 passing yards this season. Unfortunately, Oklahoma State lost a 51–49 shootout, dropping to 5–3. His personal performance deserves recognition even if the Cowboys’ record limits his Heisman prospects.

Who Lost Ground

Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State: This was not a poor individual performance. Ten receptions and a conference career touchdown record should strengthen any candidate’s résumé. But Ohio State’s second defeat and the uncertainty surrounding injured quarterback Julian Sayin complicate Smith’s campaign. His next opportunity comes against Oregon, when the Buckeyes desperately need a victory.

Jesse Legree, WR, Oregon State: Caught seven passes for 70 yards without a touchdown as the Beavers lost at Fresno State, 38–22. Legree remains one of the nation’s most productive receivers, but a third team defeat and reduced scoring production came at an unfortunate point in the season.

Kevin Jennings, QB, SMU: Completed 29 of 36 passes for 351 yards and two touchdowns against Syracuse. Yet SMU lost 30–27 on a touchdown in the final 17 seconds. Another example of an outstanding individual performance overshadowed by a damaging team defeat.

Next Saturday could rearrange the entire board.

Mensah and Carr meet in South Bend. Chambliss challenges Georgia. Smith and Ohio State face Oregon.

November is where statistical cases become Heisman moments.

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Notes, Quotes, Anecdotes — Week 9

Riley Saved Job, Then Pulled Out a Script

Lincoln Riley may have saved his job Saturday night when USC upset No. 2 Ohio State, 30–18. Then he did something almost as surprising.

At the end of his postgame press conference, the embattled coach pulled out a piece of paper and read a prepared statement defending his leadership of the Trojans.

He even stumbled over his opening sentence, initially saying the program was not built on internal joy before correcting himself.

“This program is built on internal joy, not external applause,” Riley declared.

He also reminded everybody that he considered himself the right person to coach USC.

A week earlier, a 24–7 loss at Wisconsin intensified demands for his dismissal. Now the Trojans stand 7–2, rank No. 18 nationally and remain in playoff contention after Riley’s first victory over a Top 10 opponent in five seasons at USC.

But about that statement.

If external applause does not matter, why prepare a written response for the people providing it?

USC gets a week off before visiting Indiana on November 14.

Riley might want to keep that piece of paper handy.

Norvell Fired; Even Protesters Misspelled His Name

Florida State fired Mike Norvell on Sunday, less than 24 hours after Clemson defeated the Seminoles, 36–24, in Tallahassee.

Norvell finished 41–39 over seven seasons, including a miserable 10–22 record since the beginning of 2024.

Quite a fall for a coach whose 2023 team won its first 13 games, captured the ACC championship and was controversially excluded from the four-team College Football Playoff.

Before Saturday’s game, frustrated fans hired an airplane to circle Doak Campbell Stadium trailing a banner demanding the dismissal of Norvell and Board of Trustees chairman Peter Collins.

One problem.

They spelled the coach’s name “Novell.”

Clemson coach Dabo Swinney was furious, defending Norvell after beating him. Swinney called the demonstration an embarrassment and complained that the protesters could not even spell the man’s name correctly.

Sunday, Florida State president Richard McCullough made the dismissal official. Former Seminoles quarterback Rick Stockstill, a longtime head coach at Middle Tennessee, takes over on an interim basis while the school begins a national search.

Norvell’s departure reportedly leaves Florida State facing approximately $50 million in remaining contractual obligations.

College football’s coaching business can get expensive, especially when the winning stops.

Belichick Recovers Twice, Loses Twice

Bill Belichick’s North Carolina team nearly stunned No. 1 Miami, but the final 98 seconds became an officiating adventure.

Trailing 38–35, the Tar Heels recovered an onside kick. Officials nullified it because Shamar Easter lined up offside.

North Carolina tried again.

Another recovery. Another celebration. Another penalty.

This time Peyton Seelmann was flagged for an illegal block before the football traveled the required 10 yards.

Two consecutive successful recoveries. Neither counted.

Miami recovered the third attempt and escaped Chapel Hill unbeaten.

The remarkable part came afterward. Belichick, who certainly understands the NFL and college rulebooks, did not blame the officials.

“It’s probably about right,” he said, acknowledging how close both calls were.

Seelmann also admitted contacting an opponent before the ball traveled 10 yards.

Belichick’s Tar Heels might have missed their opportunity to upset the nation’s top-ranked team, but at least their coach avoided turning two penalties into a third controversy.

BYU Wins Again; Big 12 Admits Another Mistake

BYU is becoming the Big 12’s traveling officiating seminar.

For the third consecutive week, a Cougars game produced a controversial ruling. For the second time in three weeks, the conference publicly acknowledged an error that benefited BYU.

Saturday’s disputed play occurred early in a 27–20 victory over Arizona State.

Quarterback Bear Bachmeier fumbled while attempting to score from the 1-yard line. Running back Sione Moa recovered the ball near the 2 and carried it into the end zone.

After multiple replay reviews, officials awarded BYU a touchdown.

Wrong, said the Big 12 afterward.

Under Rule 12-3-3-d-2, Moa could recover the football but not advance it because the play was initially ruled dead. BYU should have faced third-and-goal from the 2.

Two weeks earlier, the conference acknowledged that Notre Dame should have received one final play with one second remaining in its 28–24 loss at BYU.

The Cougars’ overtime defeat at UCF in between also produced questions about clock administration, although the conference issued no similar acknowledgment.

Three weeks. Three controversies. Two admitted mistakes.

And next Saturday? No. 7 BYU visits undefeated No. 3 Utah in the Holy War.

Perhaps the Big 12 should schedule an extra replay review before kickoff.

Coaching Hot Seats: Cooling and Cooking

Mike Norvell is out at Florida State. Lincoln Riley may have rescued himself at USC. Elsewhere, the coaching thermometer continues fluctuating.

Rutgers coach Greg Schiano watched Michigan escape Piscataway with a 28–21 victory, dropping the Scarlet Knights to 2–6. Back-to-back losing seasons appear increasingly likely, although a reported buyout approaching $19 million would complicate any decision to replace him.

Colorado coach Deion Sanders enjoyed a little breathing room when the Buffaloes snapped a five-game losing streak with a 27–24 overtime victory over Kansas State.

Running back Richard Young rushed for 120 yards and two touchdowns, while quarterback Isaac Wilson found Charlie Williams for the winning 11-yard touchdown pass in overtime.

Colorado improved to 3–5. Three more victories in four remaining games would make the Buffaloes bowl-eligible.

TCU coach Sonny Dykes also escaped a troublesome Saturday. His Horned Frogs trailed Kansas 13–0 at halftime before rallying for a 22–16 victory.

Quarterback Jaden Craig scored the winning touchdown on a 17-yard run with just over a minute remaining.

TCU improved to 4–4, hardly the standard Dykes established by reaching the national championship game in his first season.

Two coaches who needed victories collected them. Another coach who needed one went looking for a new job.

Nobody knows what the next Saturday will bring, which is why college football’s coaching carousel never really stops turning.

🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈

Week 9 Results, Stats

Tuesday, Oct. 27

FBS
Delaware 35, Western Kentucky 21
Missouri State 24, Sam Houston 3

Wednesday, Oct. 28

FBS
Kennesaw State 44, Middle Tennessee 28
Jacksonville State 24, New Mexico State 0

Thursday, Oct. 29

FBS
Troy 24, James Madison 21
North Texas 48, Florida Atlantic 41

FCS
South Carolina State 51, Morgan State 10

Friday, Oct. 30

FBS
Tulane 38, Charlotte 31 (OT)
Baylor 41, UCF 9
Sacramento State 31, Kent State 10

FCS
Dartmouth 24, Harvard 14

Saturday, Oct. 31

FBS
No. 5 Notre Dame 35, Navy 13
Western Michigan 23, Bowling Green 10
No. 13 Texas Tech 34, No. 22 Arizona 26
Syracuse 30, No. 19 SMU 27
Iowa 30, No. 25 Wisconsin 0
NC State 31, California 10
Duke 47, Boston College 2
Illinois 20, Maryland 17
South Florida 30, UAB 10
Michigan 28, Rutgers 21
No. 12 Ole Miss 45, Auburn 15
Marshall 36, Old Dominion 23
Colorado 27, Kansas State 24
Coastal Carolina 31, Georgia State 20
Air Force 35, UConn 26
East Carolina 17, Temple 9
Louisiana Tech 35, South Alabama 20
Louisville 52, Stanford 24
No. 3 Georgia 27, No. 17 Florida 8
No. 4 Indiana 23, Minnesota 16
No. 8 BYU 27, Arizona State 20
Oregon 34, No. 20 Northwestern 26
TCU 22, Kansas 16
Utah State 31, Colorado State 14
North Dakota State 31, UTEP 7
Liberty 49, FIU 10
Southern Mississippi 35, ULM 21
No. 6 Utah 49, Cincinnati 25
No. 14 Wake Forest 51, Virginia 7
New Mexico 21, San Jose State 16
No. 7 UCLA 27, Nevada 0
South Carolina 42, Oklahoma 25
Penn State 31, Purdue 17
Georgia Southern 19, App State 3
Iowa State 51, No. 24 Oklahoma State 49
Clemson 36, Florida State 24
San Diego State 26, Washington State 20
No. 1 Miami (Florida) 38, North Carolina 35
Southern California 30, No. 2 Ohio State 18
No. 11 Texas 31, Mississippi State 3
No. 23 Missouri 34, Arkansas 10
Pittsburgh 34, Georgia Tech 11
Washington 17, Nebraska 10
Memphis 49, Army 22
No. 20 Boise State 46, Texas State 45
UNLV 31, Northern Illinois 24
Fresno State 38, Oregon State 22

FCS
Brown 36, Penn 17
Yale 26, Columbia 8
Princeton 21, Cornell 20
Youngstown State 31, North Dakota 28
Merrimack 19, Wagner 14
Lehigh 31, Bucknell 30
Duquesne 41, New Haven 14
Villanova 44, Lafayette 21
Colgate 37, William & Mary 0
Holy Cross 33, Richmond 14
Butler 27, Presbyterian 10
Dayton 44, Stetson 34
Drake 45, Morehead State 35
Chattanooga 24, VMI 10
Illinois State 35, Murray State 14
UNI 45, Indiana State 23
North Carolina Central 34, Howard 0
Western Illinois 42, Charleston So. 35
Gardner-Webb 34, Southeast Missouri State 10
Lindenwood 27, Tennessee State 0
Western Caro. 27, Furman 26
UIW 66, Northwestern State 14
Delaware State 36, Norfolk State 33
Montana State 61, Cal Poly 7
Idaho State 34, Utah Tech 27
Northern Arizona 34, Southern Utah 27
Weber State 38, UC Davis 14
Eastern Illinois 45, UT Martin 16
SFA 37, Houston Christian 6
Mercer 28, The Citadel 19
McNeese 16, Nicholls 3
Alabama A&M 31, Alabama State 28
Tennessee Tech 24, ETSU 17
South Dakota State 31, South Dakota 21
Abilene Christian 59, West Georgia 0
Montana 42, Eastern Washington 33
Idaho 38, Portland State 14
San Diego 41, Marist 40
East Texas A&M 10, Southeastern Louisiana 7
North Alabama 14, Central Arkansas 9
Tarleton State 28, Eastern Kentucky 24
Samford 10, Wofford 9
Lamar University 52, UTRGV 23

DII

Albany State (Georgia) 21, Clark Atlanta 17
Benedict 23, Savannah State 0

DIII

Hope 48, Kalamazoo 13
Trinity (Texas) 76, Sewanee 17
Concordia Chicago 30, Eureka 0
Washington & Jeff. 42, Grove City 14

Frank Cooney

Author, journalist, football analyst and founder of NFL Draft Scout. His career spans seven decades, beginning at Hearst's San Francisco Examiner in 1965. He served on the launch teams for Madden Football and NFL on FOX, spent 33 years as a Pro Football Hall of Fame selector and entered the Semi-Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2007. Cooney publishes Football Frankly, NFL Draft Scout and Hall of Football through The Sports Xchange.